Wednesday, July 11, 2007

How bad is the problem of Illegal Immigration from Mexico to the United States?

This issue is politically hot, but no one is presenting data to quantify how bad the problem is. At one extreme, there are those stating that illegal mexican immigrants are just wanting to unite their families which are split accross borders. At the other extreme, there are those who state that Mexico is using demographic warfare to take back the United States Southwest (comprising California, Nevada, Arizona and Texas - which they call Aztlan).

The numbers used in this data are approximate, so as to make the comparisons easy to understand.

The population of the United States: 300 million

The population of Mexico: 110 million

The Hispanic population in the US is 12%. Hispanic does not mean Mexican - it means anyone who has ancestry tracing back to Spain. Not all the 12% are from Mexico.

The Mexican-American population in the United states: 8%
It is unclear that this statistic counts only citizens or if it also includes illegal immigrants from Mexico.

The highest estimate of illegal immigrants in the US: 20 million
The 20 million are multi-racial, but for the sake of this data, lets assume they are all from Mexico. This is 6.5% of the US population.

The Asian population of the United States is much smaller = 4%. It is mentioned here only to give a comparison to another ethnic group.

It is reasonable to assume that the 8% of Mexican Americans in the United States actually includes a count of the illegal immigrants from Meixco, but for the sake of arguement, lets assume the opposite and treat them seperately, for a total of 14.5%.

California has 11% of the US population. It is obvious that not all Californians are Hispanic. The highest estimate is 33% of Californians are Hispanic.

One thing to consider is the loyalty of Mexican Americans. It is impossible to measure loyalty except through action. It is reasonable to assume that the vast majority of Mexican-American US Citizens are loyal to the United States. They may have tender feelings towards their ancestral home, but the United states is their home.

According to FAIR, the cost of ALL illegal immigrants is 9 Billion dollars a year.
7.5 Billion is for education costs. The two largest costs of the remaining 1.5 Billion dollars is for medical treatment and prison costs.

The budget of the United States is 2.5 Trillion dollars. The cost of illegal immigration is 0.36 percent. In comparison, it is very small, and is probably not likely to greatly affect the US economy.

The total amount of money spent on publicly funded education in the United States for Primary and secondary Education is 550 Billion Dollars. The cost of educating the children of illegal immigrants is only 1.4% of the total costs. The children of illegal immigrants, if born in the United States, are citizens, and therefore have a right to publically funded education, even though their parents may not be contributing to public funds via taxation. The average cost per student of public funds for Primary and Secondary education in the United States is 10,000 dollars. The 7.5 billion dollars spent on educating the children of illegal immigrants represents 750,000 students, out of a total of 55 million.

The unemployment rate in the United States is 5.5% Since the percentage of illegal Mexican immigrants is 6.5%, one might say that if the illegal immigrants were removed, all the 5.5% would become employed. This is probably not true. Most of the US unemployed are opting not to take low end positions so that they are free to find a higher paying job. It is verified that most of the 6.5% of illegal Mexican immigrants are working in low end jobs as laborers.

Therefore, it is reasonable to assume that the woes of the US economy are not caused by illegal immigration.

No comments: